The Revenue or Profiteer? A proposed amended criticism filed towards Marcus Lemonis, the star of CNBC’s “The Revenue,” alleges that he targets small corporations via his present and saddles them with debt in a scheme to take over the businesses.
Getty Pictures for MARCUS
A group of greater than 50 companies which have appeared on CNBC’s hit actuality present “The Revenue” allege that the present’s star Marcus Lemonis and the TV community use the collection as a guise to defraud and damage small companies.
A proposed amended criticism filed on Saturday with america District Court docket for the Southern District of New York alleges that Lemonis, NBCUniversal, and manufacturing firm Machete employed mob-like techniques towards corporations which have appeared on “The Revenue” to defraud enterprise homeowners and take their corporations.
“Marcus Lemonis is a wolf in sheep’s clothes, and a false prophet who makes use of his fame and fortune to steal small companies from on a regular basis Individuals,” states the proposed amended criticism. “Via NBC’s tv present, The Revenue, Lemonis presents himself as a savior of struggling small enterprise homeowners, all of the whereas preying on the enterprise he purports to be saving.”
The submitting says that an eight-month investigation revealed that not less than 51 corporations which have appeared on the present suffered the same “hellish nightmare” and sample of humiliation, fraud, extortion and different fees.
“Lemonis strategically and intentionally drowns these companies in debt to him and his entities as a way to foreclose on them and take their belongings and mental property to increase his personal empire,” the submitting states.
The premise of the present, which is in its eighth season on CNBC, is that Lemonis, who can be the CEO of Tenting World Holdings, a Lincolnshire, Illinois-based firm that sells leisure autos and tenting provides, makes an funding in a struggling enterprise after which helps pull off a enterprise makeover.
For years, nevertheless, small enterprise homeowners who’ve been on the present have alleged that there’s a dark side to the man known as The Profit. Lemonis has denied any wrongdoing and recommended any corporations which might be sad with their firm’s efficiency ought to look within the mirror.
Lemonis, when reached for remark, didn’t mince phrases. “This looks like a grand shake down from people who find themselves not entitled to something,” Lemonis says.
Lemonis continues: “In each single enterprise that I’ve ever tried to assist, or made a grant to, or made a mortgage to, or an funding to, particularly associated to this present, and the fact releases they signed, I’ve solely ever put cash into individuals’s companies and by no means as soon as received any type of cost again together with bills, curiosity, precept, something.”
CNBC, via a spokesperson, mentioned “no remark.”
The proposed amended criticism is a part of a lawsuit first filed towards Lemonis final yr by Nicolas Goureau and his sister Stephanie Menkin, who appeared on the present in 2014 with their mom hoping to chop a cope with Lemonis to assist develop their family-owned clothes boutique. Braveness.B, which Noemi Goureau, the household matriarch, began in 2008 via the household enterprise Gooberry, had seven places in cities like Aspen, New York and Palm Seaside and pulled in $5.5 million in annual income.
Lemonis struck a cope with the household to take a position $800,000 for a 32% stake within the enterprise, however the shareholder settlement, based on the criticism, gave Lemonis what amounted to finish management over the corporate’s funds. The capital for the funding was funded via a line of credit score at 5% curiosity with an organization related to Lemonis and solely $200,000 was alleged to go in direction of renovations and rebranding, however he spent $2 million, or ten instances extra, the lawsuit claims.
When Goureau and Menkin approached Lemonis in regards to the skyrocketing renovation prices, Lemonis mentioned in the event that they need to again out of the deal, they may pay him again for the renovations, which they may not afford. All through the years, Lemonis allegedly saddled the corporate with extra debt, had the corporate purchase stock and promote it at a loss, and purchase different corporations it couldn’t afford, the criticism says.
“From June 2014 to current, with Lemonis’ ‘assist,’ Gooberry has gone from a valuation of roughly $2.6 million to being virtually bancrupt,” the unique criticism reads.
The lawsuit seeks damages of a minimum of $12 million and alleges fraudulent inducement, unjust enrichment, breach of fiduciary responsibility, and different fees together with violations of the Racketeering Influenced and Corrupt Organizations Act.
Lemonis says that the three members of the family made about $3 million in wages over time and he alleges that they charged $1.3 million in private bills on the corporate bank card.
“The excellent news about being in America is that it’s the house of the free, the courageous and the individuals who wish to shake you down,” says Lemonis. “Nicolas is in large bother as a result of he realizes that he’s performed some issues that he shouldn’t have.”
Goureau denies any wrongdoing. “If CNBC did their homework and listened to numerous warnings from individuals, he wouldn’t have had the platform to harm individuals then, now and later,” says Goureau.
The Revenue has been operating on CNBC for eight years and is among the community’s best-performing reveals.
WireImage
In an unrelated case—a petition for chapter safety for an organization named Tumbleweed Tiny Homes, which appeared on “The Revenue” and owes an organization associated to Tenting World greater than $2 million—filings present that the 51 corporations are in search of a settlement with Lemonis and an unnamed entity for alleged “unlawful actions surrounding the tv present ‘The Revenue’” and can go into mediation on the finish of September.
Lemonis says he has not agreed to attend the mediation. “If it’s headed to mediation, I’m unsure who’s going to be there,” he says.
Gerard Fox, the Los Angeles-based legal professional who’s representing Goureau and his sister and the 51 different corporations, says he has an settlement signed by Lemonis’ lawyer that he’s dedicated to attending mediation.
In one other lawsuit filed towards Lemonis by the founding father of New York-based firm Bowery Kitchen Provides, a decide dismissed the allegations involving violations of the RICO Act. The case is ongoing with trademark and unfair competitors associated allegations.
Pete Athans, who appeared on “The Revenue” in 2014 together with his Illinois-based automotive dealership Athans Motors, says that he needs he by no means appeared on the CNBC actuality present.
“He ruined greater than my firm—he ruined my life,” says Athans, who’s a part of the group of corporations headed into mediation.
Certainly one of Lemonis’ former executives, who isn’t celebration to any lawsuit or mediation, says the best way Lemonis treats the enterprise homeowners who seem on his present is “unethical.”
“The mob has this factor known as a bust out—when you owe them cash, they take over your enterprise and so they put a number of debt on it…your enterprise is decimated, your credit score is decimated,” the previous govt says, who needed to stay nameless for concern of retribution. “It’s a model of a bust out, is what he’s performed. He did that to Nicolas, he did that to different corporations too.”
Lemonis, who will host a collection on HGTV “The Renovator” beginning subsequent yr and has his personal podcast produced by Wondery, flatly denies any wrongdoing: “I didn’t do something flawed, ever,” he says.
NBCUniversal and guardian firm Comcast didn’t reply to a number of requests for remark.
On Tuesday night time, “The Revenue” premiered its first episode of its eight season. In the course of the one-hour present, Lemonis tried to chop a cope with a mainstay pizza parlor in Santa Monica, California that has racked up tens of hundreds of {dollars} in debt. After giving the pizza joint a makeover, Lemonis lorded over what devolved right into a daytime cleaning soap opera-level drama between the proprietor and associate.
At one level throughout the present, Lemonis asks the proprietor: “Would you like me to take a position on this shitbox proper now? As a result of I’m not going to do this.”